🌙

Best Sleep Supplements (2026)

Natural sleep aids and relaxation supplements

18 products reviewed and ranked · Updated February 2026

Our #1 Pick

Nature Made Melatonin 5mg

Nature Made · $8-12 · Tablet

"USP Verified melatonin at the most popular dose"

Nature Made Melatonin 5mg is the safe, verified choice for sleep support. The USP verification is especially important for melatonin, as studies have found many melatonin supplements contain significantly more or less than labeled. With Nature Made, you know you're getting exactly 5mg.

USP Verified Non-GMO Gluten Free

Full Rankings

#	Product	Price	Amazon	Rating
1	Nature Made Melatonin 5mg Nature Made · Tablet	$8-12	4.7 55,000+	8.3
2	Momentous Huberman Lab Sleep Pack Momentous · Capsule Pack	$48-58	4.4 3,000+	8.5
3	Natrol Melatonin 5mg Gummies Natrol · Gummy	$10-14	4.5 75,000+	7.5
4	Nature Made Melatonin 3mg (240 Tablets) Nature Made · Tablet	$8-12	4.7 34,000+	8.2
5	OLLY Sleep Gummies OLLY · Gummy	$14-18	4.5 80,000+	7.8
6	Natrol Melatonin 5mg Time Release Natrol · Tablet (Time Release)	$8-12	4.5 62,000+	7.8
7	OLLY Sleep Gummy OLLY · Gummy	$14-18	4.5 95,000+	7.5
8	NOW Foods L-Tryptophan 500mg (120 Veggie Caps) NOW Foods · Veggie Capsule	$18-24	4.5 8,800+	7.8
9	Nature Made Melatonin 3mg (240 Tablets) Nature Made · Tablet	$10-14	4.7 42,200+	8.6
10	Natrol Melatonin 5mg Time Release (250 Tablets) Natrol · Tablet	$12-16	4.5 62,400+	8.3
11	Natrol 5-HTP 200mg Time Release Natrol · Tablet	$10-14	4.4 22,000+	7.8
12	Natrol Melatonin 5mg Time Release Natrol · Tablet	$8-12	4.5 65,000+	8.0
13	Natrol Melatonin 10mg Gummies Natrol · Gummy	$10-14	4.5 30,000+	7.4
14	OLLY Sleep Gummy Blackberry Zen (50 Gummies) OLLY · Gummy	$14-18	4.5 86,200+	8.3
15	Natrol Melatonin 10mg Natrol · Tablet	$8-12	4.5 85,000+	7.2
16	Natrol 5-HTP 200mg Time Release Natrol · Tablet	$10-14	4.4 15,000+	7.8
17	Irwin Naturals Power to Sleep PM Irwin Naturals · Softgel	$14-20	4.3 18,000+	7.3
18	OLLY Immunity Sleep Gummy OLLY · Gummy	$14-18	4.5 16,000+	7.2

Browse Other Categories